Homemade Pierogi

My late mother-in-law Catherine was a legendary cook and baker. My husband always talks so fondly of how many bake sales she contributed to and how people would flock to parties she threw because they knew how incredible the food she served would be. This homemade pierogi recipe is her Polish pride right on the plate and she contributed it to a cookbook that raised money for my sister-in-law’s dance school. I made these for the first time with my sister-in-law one afternoon and we had such a blast doing it. I decided I wanted to make them again for my in-laws when we had them over for dinner last night and they came out just as amazing as I remembered!

The potatoes boiling for the homemade pierogi filling.
The first order of business was to boil the potatoes for the filling of the homemade pierogi. They needed to cook for about 20-25 minutes to become tender enough to mash.
Pretty little ball of homemade pierogi dough!
As the potatoes cooked, I made the amazing dough. Four ingredients and a little elbow grease were all it took to make it. The sour cream was the key to giving it tang and perfect texture. There was no special equipment needed! Then I let it rest for 30 minutes so that the gluten could relax.
The amazing potato and cheese filling for the pierogi.
While the dough rested, I finished the filling. I just stirred all of the ingredients together and it was done. This potato and cheese filling was classic and so amazing. It’s my favorite filling for homemade pierogi hands down. That’s saying a lot since I love them all!
Cutting out the pierogi circles.
I used a 4 inch round cutter to cut out perfect rounds out of the dough after it rested. That measure yielded 24 circles to form the homemade pierogi.
Crimping the edge of the pierogi with a fork.
I scooped a couple of tablespoons of filling onto one half of the dough circle before I brought the other half over to enclose it. To really seal the homemade pierogi, I pressed along the edge with a fork. It also made them prettier!

All of the formed pierogi boiled in the same starchy, salty water that I boiled the potatoes in. It only took a minute. Then I tossed them with butter and onion in my cast iron skillet to make them golden. After that, the homemade pierogi were ready to serve! I also had boiled up a ring of kielbasa to go with them to have a truly perfect Polish feast.

The ring of kielbasa, quarted and boiling for 40 minutes. No need to do anything more to it than that!
The ring of kielbasa boiled for about 30 minutes after I quartered it. It was so perfect to go with the homemade pierogi.

It was really an honor to make this dinner of homemade pierogi and kielbasa for my in-laws and husband. The luscious lemon coconut bars I made for dessert ended the meal perfectly, another tribute to Catherine. Since I never had the pleasure of meeting my mother-in-law, learning her recipes is such an amazing way for me to feel like I know her and connect with her. Isn’t that such a beautiful thing food can do?

Homemade Pierogi
Homemade Pierogi
5 from 1 vote
Homemade Pierogi
Homemade Pierogi
Prep Time
40 mins
Cook Time
40 mins
Total Time
1 hr 20 mins
 

Homemade Pierogi filled with a luscious potato and cheese filling. Serving them alongside a ring of kielbasa made for the perfect Polish feast!

Course: Main Course
Keyword: Homemade Pierogi, Pierogi
Servings: 24 pierogi
Calories: 393 kcal
Author: Jeanie and Lulu's Kitchen
Ingredients
FOR THE DOUGH
  • 2 cups all-purpose flour
  • 8 ounces sour cream
  • 1 whole egg
  • 1/2 teaspoon salt
FOR THE FILLING
  • 10 whole yukon gold potatoes peeled and quartered
  • 1 container farmer's cheese 8 ounce size
  • 6 slices yellow American cheese
  • 1 tablespoon butter
  • 1 pinch salt plus additional as needed
FOR FINISHING
  • 1 tablespoon butter
  • 1 whole onion peeled and thinly sliced
Instructions
  1. First, start preparing the filling. Fill a large pot with cold water and put it on the stove, then salt the water generously. Get the peeled and quartered potatoes into the pot and bring the water to a boil. Boil the potatoes until they are completely tender and mashable, about 20-25 minutes.
  2. In the meantime, make the dough so it can rest. In a bowl combine the flour, sour cream, egg and salt. Stir it together completely and then turn it out onto a lightly floured surface. Knead it for a couple of minutes to have it come together in a wonderful ball of dough. Wrap it in plastic and set it aside to rest for about 30 minutes. This will allow the gluten in the flour to relax and make for a really tender homemade pierogi dough.
  3. When the potatoes are done, it's time to make the filling. Remove them from the water with a slotted spoon and transfer them to a very large bowl. Do not drain the water, leave the pot of water on the stove gently boiling. There is a master plan behind this, I promise! Mash the potatoes in the bowl and stir in the farmer cheese, american cheese and butter until it becomes a creamy, luscious filling. Add salt to taste, a big pinch should do it. Set the filling aside.

  4. When the dough is done resting, divide it in half. Roll out the first half to about 1/4 an inch thick on a floured surface with a floured rolling pin. With a 4 inch round cutter, cut out perfect little circles. You should get nine circles the first time. Take the scraps and roll them out again to cut out another 3. Repeat this process with the other half of dough to get 24 circles total.
  5. Fill each of the circles with two tablespoons of filling on one half, then bring the other half over to enclose it and pinch it together thoroughly. Really seal them even more and make a pretty pattern along the edge by pressing down with the tines of a fork over the whole edge. You might have some filling leftover. You can seal it and freeze it to make these again or even fill puff pastry cups with it for an appetizer. 

  6. Gently drop the pierogi into the pot of boiling water you used for the potatoes. That extra starchiness just makes them! They only need to boil for a minute. Remove them with a slotted spoon to a platter. Then it's time to finish them up! Heat the butter in a large cast iron skillet. Let the sliced onion get soft and fragrant in it for a minute. Gently toss the pierogi in the pan with the onion to let them get slightly golden. Then plate them and serve them immediately! Serve with kielbasa to have a perfect Polish feast.
Nutrition Facts
Homemade Pierogi
Amount Per Serving (4 pierogi)
Calories 393 Calories from Fat 189
% Daily Value*
Fat 21g32%
Saturated Fat 12.6g79%
Cholesterol 83mg28%
Sodium 918mg40%
Potassium 722mg21%
Carbohydrates 34.7g12%
Fiber 4.4g18%
Sugar 4.6g5%
Protein 15.3g31%
Calcium 130mg13%
Iron 1.3mg7%
* Percent Daily Values are based on a 2000 calorie diet.

SaveSave

Homemade Pierogi filled with a luscious potato and cheese filling. Serving them alongside a ring of kielbasa made for the perfect Polish feast! #pierogi #homemadepierogi #polishfood #potatopierogi #jeanieandluluskitchen
Homemade Pierogi

10 thoughts on “Homemade Pierogi”

  1. That’s a really nice recipe! My parents come from Ukraine and I’ve been eating pierogies all my life, and we never use American cheese, but I guess that’s a nice twist to traditional recipe

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating